Obtaining Exclusive Rights for Your Invention in the United States
|Written by Gene Quinn
Patent Attorney & Founder of IPWatchdog
Widerman & Malek
Blog | Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn
Posted: May 24, 2014 @ 8:00 am
Do You Have a New Invention Idea?
CLICK HERE to Submit your Invention. 100% Confidential. No Obligation.
Whether you are an independent inventor, an fledgling entrepreneur or a seasoned inventor who is going out on your own for the first time, the best thing you can do for yourself is to become familiar with the concepts and procedure associated with protecting your inventions. Obtaining patents is not easy for the uninitiated, and without some familiarity you will be wandering aimlessly and wholly incapable of making sound business decisions. Simply stated: Inventors who are completely unfamiliar with the patent process also won’t be able to help in any meaningful way with the patent process, and they will make poor strategic decisions that can lead to the loss of all rights.
So let’s start with the basics. A patent is a proprietary right granted by the United States federal government to an inventor who files a patent application with the United States Patent Office. Therefore, unlike copyright and trademark protection, patent protection will only exist upon the issuance of a patent, which requires you to file a patent application. Simply stated, if you do not obtain a patent you have no exclusive rights. This is why inventors should never disclose their invention outside of a confidential relationship. Such a relationship is legally created immediately upon seeking professional advice from a patent attorney or patent agent, but in all other situations if you do not have a patent you should be extremely cautious about disclosing invention information without a confidentiality agreement. What others learn from you outside of a confidential relationship can be used with or without your permission, and without giving you any compensation.
Furthermore, despite what you may have been told or read, keeping a detailed invention notebook, even if you mail a description of the invention to yourself, provides no exclusive rights whatsoever. It is extremely important to keep detailed invention records in case you ever need to prove the particular date you invented, which even in some extremely limited ways may still be relevant even under a first to file regime ushered in by the America Invents Act (AIA), but keeping such records will never provide you any exclusive rights. You absolutely must file a patent application and have that application mature into an issued patent in order to obtain exclusive rights to your invention.
There are essentially three types of patent applications that can be filed. These are:
— Non-provisional Patent Application, which would lead to a utility patent that protects the operation and functionality of an invention.
— Design Patent Application, which would lead to a design patent that protects the way an invention looks, but not how it operates or functions.
— Plant Patent Application, which protects new and distinct asexually reproduced varieties of plants, other than those that are tuber propagated.
Each type of patent confers to the patent owner “the right to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale, or selling” the invention in the United States or importing the invention into the United States. It is important to note, however, that patents do not protect ideas, but rather protect inventions and methods that exhibit patentable subject matter. In the United States virtually everything can and does qualify as patentable subject matter. You can patent new and unique machines, devices, process of doing something, process of making something, living matter (such as a bio-engineered organism), business methods, software, compounds and much more, including improvements that relate to any of the aforementioned types of invention. Those things that cannot be patented include laws of nature, mathematical equations, physical phenomena, abstract ideas, slogans, tradenames or literary works. Literary works can be protected under copyright laws, and slogans or tradenames can be protected under trademark laws.
You can also file what is called a provisional patent application, which is really a precursor to a non-provisional patent application. Unlike the other patent applications mentioned above, a provisional patent application will not mature into an issued patent. A provisional patent application instead acts as an economical way to start the patenting process by securing a priority filing date, which also affords the applicant the right to legally say that there is a “patent pending.” There are few formalities required for filing a provisional patent application, and the Patent Office fee is less than filing a non-provisional patent application. Independent inventors should, therefore, strongly consider starting with a provisional patent application. Before considering a provisional patent application I strongly recommend inventors read The Good, Bad & Ugly: Truth About Provisional Patent Applications. If you are going to file a provisional patent application it must be done properly in order to provide any benefit later. I am a big fan of proper provisional patent applications, which can be particularly helpful for securing a filing date while you continue to refine aspects of the invention, but a provisional patent application is only as good as the disclosure filed.
If you are going to ultimately receive a patent, whether you start with a provisional patent application or not, you are going to need to file a non-provisional patent application within 12 months of filing your provisional patent application. Without knowing a good deal about an invention it is very difficult if not completely impossible to give a ballpark estimate as to likely costs associated with filing a non-provisional patent application. Nevertheless, for some rough guidance regarding what you can expect to pay in attorneys fees through filing of a non-provisional patent application please see Cost of Obtaining a Patent.
For more information on the patent application process please see our Overview of the Patent Process and A Beginner’s Guide to Patents and the Patent Process. If you are stuck at the idea stage in your invention I recommend reading Moving from Idea to Patent and Protecting Your Invention When You Need Help. If you are contemplating whether you want to work with an invention company to help procure patent protection and obtain marketing assistance, please first read The Truth About Invention Promotion Companies and How to Find Valuable Invention Services.For those who would like to try and draft and file their own patent applications, I have developed a unique process called the Invent & Patent System, which allows inventors to do much of their own work toward preparing and filing patent applications. You can then take the output of the system and file it as a provisional patent application, or you could have an attorney or agent take what you provide to create either a provisional patent application or non-provisional patent application and file it for you. The system gives you the inventor the choice with respect to how much you want to do on your own. Since its inception in 2004, this system has helped independent inventors file tens of thousands of provisional patent applications. Of course, if you can afford to hire an attorney to represent you that is the way to get the best patent application and ultimately the broadest patent rights.
If you are going to attempt to do things on your own and file a provisional or non-provisional patent application without the assistance of a patent attorney or patent agent, I strongly recommend reading these patent drafting articles that contain numerous tips and suggestions for making a better, more complete disclosure:
- A Patent Drafting Checklist Oct 07 2014
- The Patent Drafting Disclosure Revolution: Don’t Ask Alice Sep 30 2014
- Patent Drafting: Ambiguity and Assumptions are the Enemy Sep 27 2014
- Patent Drafting: Getting the Broadest Supportable Claim Scope Sep 23 2014
- Patent Drafting: Employing Claim Differentiation to Ensure Broad Construction Sep 16 2014
- Patent Drafting: Broadening Statements vs. Boilerplate Language Sep 02 2014
- Patent Drafting: Appropriately Disclosing Your Invention Aug 30 2014
- Patent Drafting: Include Alternatives and Variations to Claim Limitations Aug 26 2014
- Patent Drafting: The Detailed Description Should Include Multiple Embodiments or Examples Aug 19 2014
- Rules of Patent Drafting: The Disclosure Revolution Aug 12 2014
- How to Describe an Invention in a Patent Application Aug 09 2014
- Patent Drawings 101: The Way to Better Patent Applications Aug 02 2014
- Understanding Patent Claims Jul 12 2014
- Patent Drafting: Top 5 Critical Things to Remember May 31 2014
- Patent Drafting: Not as Easy as You Think May 17 2014
- Completely Describe Your Invention in a Patent Application May 10 2014
- Software Patent Basics: What Level of Description is Required? Jan 25 2014
- Good, Bad & Ugly: Truth About Provisional Patent Applications Oct 19 2013
- Conjunctions and/or Patent Claims Oct 17 2013
- Drafting Patent Applications: Writing Method Claims Oct 11 2013
- The Benefits of a Provisional Patent Application Sep 14 2013
- Turn Your Idea into an Invention with a Good Description Sep 01 2013
- Patent Drafting: What is the Patentable Feature? Aug 17 2013
- Patent Claim Drafting 101: The Basics May 25 2013
- A Guide to Patenting Software: Getting Started Feb 16 2013
- Does the term “Invention” in the Specification Limit the Claims? Feb 13 2013
- Working with Patent Drawings to Create a Complete Disclosure Feb 09 2013
- Patent Drafting: Describing What is Unique Without Puffing May 26 2012
- A Primer on Indefiniteness and Means-Plus-Function Apr 18 2012
- Patent Claim Drafting: Improvements and Jepson Claims Mar 29 2012
- Patent Drafting: Drilling Down on Variations in a Patent Application Jan 13 2012
- An Introduction to Patent Claims Dec 23 2011
- Patent Drafting Lessons: Learning from the Grappling Dummy Aug 20 2011
- Patenting Business Methods and Software in the U.S. Jul 18 2011
- Defining the Full Glory of Your Invention in a Patent Application Jun 04 2011
- Patent Drafting: Language Difficulties, Open Mouth Insert Foot May 03 2011
- The Key to Drafting an Excellent Patent – Alternatives Apr 01 2011
- Tricks & Tips for Describing An Invention in a Patent Application Mar 19 2011
- Patent Drafting: Defining Computer Implemented Processes Mar 14 2011
If you feel like you need the assistance of a patent attorney please contact me to discuss how I might be able to help.
About the Author
Gene Quinn is a US Patent Attorney, law professor and the founder of IPWatchdog.com. He is also a principal lecturer in the top patent bar review course in the nation, which helps aspiring patent attorneys and patent agents prepare themselves to pass the patent bar exam. Gene started the widely popular intellectual property website IPWatchdog.com in 1999, and since that time the site has had many millions of unique visitors. Gene has been quoted in the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, the LA Times, USA Today, CNN Money, NPR and various other newspapers and magazines worldwide. He represents individuals, small businesses and start-up corporations. As an electrical engineer with a computer engineering focus his specialty is electronic and computer devices, Internet applications, software and business methods.