Moving from Idea to Patent – When Do You Have an Invention?
|Written by Gene Quinn
Patent Attorney & Founder of IPWatchdog
Zies, Widerman & Malek
Blog | Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn
Posted: Jun 21, 2014 @ 1:57 pm
Do You Have a New Invention Idea?
CLICK HERE to Submit your Invention. 100% Confidential. No Obligation.
How to Patent an Invention Idea | Moving from Idea to Patent
By now everyone has undoubtedly seen the late night television commercials, and the online ads offering to help you patent your invention idea. Despite what these advertisements suggest, you cannot patent or protect an idea, but don’t despair. The idea is the first critical step toward being able to obtain a patent, and in my experience many inventors think they only have an idea and are not yet at the invention stage when, in fact, they really do have an invention that could be protected.
In order to get from where you are to where you want to be you will need to move from idea to invention and ultimately to a patent application, but the idea gets the ball rolling. But in order to get that ball rolling what you need is a strategy to help you move past the idea and learn to describe your idea with enough specifics so that it no longer is what the law would call a “mere idea.” In a nutshell, if you can describe your idea with enough detail you don’t have an idea, what you have is an invention, or at least the makings of an invention. For example, an idea is this: I want to catch mice. An invention is a mousetrap.
It is critical for inventors to document and expand upon any idea. If you continually add more details you will at some point cross over the idea/invention boundary and be squarely on the invention side of the line, which is the goal. What you want to do is explain your idea, as well as any and all aspects and alternatives associated with your idea. This will then get you toward approaching the point where it becomes specific enough for it to be considered an invention. When you reach this point you have something that can be protected and patented.
In order to protect an idea it must mature into an invention first. This means that you need to be able to explain to others how to make and use the invention so that they could replicate the invention after simply reading your description of the invention in a patent application. A patent application does not need to provide blue-print level detail, but rather it must teach those who have skill in the area you are innovating what they need to know to be able to carry out the invention. You also do not need to have a prototype, but you will need to be able to describe the invention with detail, providing sketches showing your inventive contribution. See Working With Patent Drawings to Create a Complete Disclosure. In order to get this far it is common for inventors to seek assistance from a product development company, such as Enhance Product Development, a sponsor here on IPWatchdog that offers a full range of development services for all types of inventions.
If you do not have the ability to illustrate your invention yourself can obtain patent drawings from a patent illustrator for quite cheap usually. You might also want to work with a company that provides 3D renderings, or an engineering firm that can assist you as you attempt to breathe life into your idea to get it across that idea/invention boundary and squarely into being an invention. In fact, having quality patent drawings is the single best and most economical way to broaden and expand any patent application. Having 3D renderings is also the best and most economical way to have something that is eye catching to show to those who are interested in your project, whether it be those who might fund the project or those who might be interested in licensing or acquiring your rights.
Unfortunately, if you are stuck at the idea stage of the invention process you are not ready to file a patent application and also you do not want to run out and start telling people or submitting your idea to companies. Many companies do not accept the submission of ideas, because ideas are not legally protected and, as such, are free to be taken by others. Some companies that do accept idea submissions will tell you that they reserve the right to use whatever you submit without compensation, so be very careful if you are submitting ideas yourself and not engaging the assistance of a licensing expert.
If you do tell a company your idea and then later they develop the same idea this leads to people believing, sometimes rightly so, that their ideas may have been taken. Many companies, however, have extensive research and development going on all the time, so it is just as likely (if not far more likely) that your idea overlapped with something they were already working on. For this reason, many companies will not accept idea submissions, but rather accept submissions only of inventions that have a patent application pending. Companies that will listen to your ideas alone (i.e., without a patent pending or issued) should be thoroughly vetted before you trust them. Without patent protection there is no way to protect an idea absent a confidentiality agreement, and without such an agreement your ideas are legally free to be taken and used without your permission. For that reason, before you proceed to starting telling people about your invention you really should consider having at least a provisional patent application on file, or working with a reputable licensing agent that has a track record working with reputable companies that are looking for ideas and inventions to license or acquire.
So what to do if you are stuck and need to move forward? One thing that I recommend is that you consider using the Invent & Patent System™ to help you flesh out your idea and put enough meat on the bones of the idea so that it will be transformed into a detailed description and invention. I created the Invent & Patent System™ to help me teach my law students how to write patent applications. It was so successful that I adapted it for use by independent inventors, and since 2004 it has been used successfully to help many thousands of inventors create and file their own provisional patent applications. In the latest version the system has been expanded even more to provide coaching, examples and templates that help inventors flesh out their inventions as they answer a series of 10 questions. So before you think you do not have an invention and all you have is an idea you might want to consider giving the Invent & Patent System™ a try. If you seriously answer the 10 questions, use the suggested answer templates and read the guidance provided to explain the point of each question you will be coached through providing enough information to transform your idea into an invention and you will have a disclosure appropriate for filing as a provisional patent application (I give you a patent sample template, the forms you need and detailed instructions).
You could also tell others about your idea in order to search for help, but I only recommend you do this with a signed confidentiality agreement in place. A confidentiality agreement, sometimes referred to as a non-disclosure agreement or NDA, is simply a contract between two or more parties where the subject of the agreement is a promise that information conveyed will be maintained in secrecy. For more on getting help see Inventing 101: Protecting Your Invention When You Need Help.Confidentiality agreements come in a variety of forms. There are one sided agreements where one party is the disclosing party and the other party is the receiving party, and there are agreements where both parties are obligated to maintain secrecy. The mutual confidentiality agreement is useful when both parties will be conveying confidential information, such as for inventor groups or when the parties are exchanging information as a preliminary step to negotiating a business deal. Unilateral confidentiality agreements are useful when only one party is turning over confidential information, perhaps to a potential investor or prospective licensee. For more information on Confidentiality Agreements, including free samples that you can download and use, go to Free Sample Confidentiality Agreements.
Next, you might be able to locate some college students or graduate students who would be interested in working with you on your project. If you have a nearby university consider posting a notice on the bulletin board of the engineering school (probably requires college permission), or contacting the school directly to see if they might be willing to circulate your request for you. Many schools are more than happy to help their students find real world experience, particularly if you are willing to pay something for the student to work on your project. Indeed, finding college students to work for little or nothing is not so difficult, and in fact if you are willing to pay you might be surprised that you are able to draw from the top of the class. Remember, college students are poor, and graduate students have been in that state of poor for some time. They need the experience, resume fluff and some money to hold them over between student loan distributions, and their skills are very up to date. Of course, have them sign at least a simple confidentiality agreement.
You can also reach out to friends and family. You might be surprised what they can tell you and what directions they can point you in. A trusted friend who is analytical, creative or mechanically inclined can be a great source. Of course, you should still get some kind of written confidentiality agreement. This is not because you are afraid your friend or family member will steal the idea, but because once you start telling people about your inventions your right to keep the invention as a trade secret is completely lost unless you have such a confidentiality agreement. Furthermore, you might lose the right to ultimately apply for a patent. Some kind of agreement, even a watered down agreement that is non-threatening is key. For a non-threatening agreement try something like this: Simple Confidentiality Agreement. This agreement shouldn’t threaten anyone. It simply explains the importance under the patent and trade secret laws that your invention remain a secret.
Another idea is to join a local inventors group. These groups are all over the country and provide members a way to bounce ideas of each other. You can learn where to go to get reliable help and steps to follow in your invention pursuit. Some of these groups also have an online presence as well. They are truly a great resource for new and experienced inventors alike. Active groups will even meet in the real world and will frequently have guest speakers to address common issues. Many times these speakers are either patent attorneys in the area or successful inventors.
You can also learn a lot about how to do things by searching for and reading related patents. This is a great way to see what else is being done in the area of your invention. For information on how to conduct your own patent search online see Patent Searching 101. Once you have something that starts to look like an invention you should consider filing a patent.
For more information on patent basics please see the articles below. Good luck, and happy inventing!
- Are you Ready to File a Provisional Patent Application? Oct 25 2014
- Why Inventors Should Not Rely On Their Own Search Oct 11 2014
- How to Describe an Invention in a Patent Application Aug 09 2014
- Utility Patent Applications – Content and Substance Jun 28 2014
- Moving from Idea to Patent – When Do You Have an Invention? Jun 21 2014
- The Patent Process on a Tight But Realistic Budget Jun 14 2014
- The Risk of Not Immediately Filing a Patent Application Jun 07 2014
- Patent Drafting: Not as Easy as You Think May 17 2014
- The Story of How Patents Promote Innovation May 12 2014
- Completely Describe Your Invention in a Patent Application May 10 2014
- Why Do You Want a Patent? Feb 08 2014
- When is an Invention Obvious? Feb 01 2014
- A Better Mouse Trap: Patents and the Road to Riches Dec 21 2013
- Keep Your Money In Your Wallet Until Proof of Concept Nov 23 2013
- The Benefits of a Provisional Patent Application Sep 14 2013
- Turn Your Idea into an Invention with a Good Description Sep 01 2013
- Patent Drafting: What is the Patentable Feature? Aug 17 2013
- Should I File a Patent Before Licensing the Invention? Aug 11 2013
- Strong Design Patents: The Power of The Broken Line Jul 30 2013
- What is a Patent? Understanding Patents and Patent Law 101 Jun 29 2013
- Patent Claim Drafting 101: The Basics May 25 2013
- A Brave New Patent World – First to File Becomes Law Mar 16 2013
- Applying for a Patent in the U.S. Feb 23 2013
- Patent Searches: A Great Opportunity to Focus on What is Unique Dec 22 2012
- Don’t be Fooled, Drafting Patents is Complicated Dec 20 2012
- A Beginner’s Guide to Patents and the Patent Process Dec 01 2012
- The Business Responsible Approach to Inventing Sep 22 2012
- Inventing 101: Protecting Your Invention When You Need Help Sep 21 2012
- Patent Reality: Basement Prices Mean Basement Quality Aug 11 2012
- Understanding Obviousness: John Deere and the Basics Jun 16 2012
- Patent Drafting: Describing What is Unique Without Puffing May 26 2012
- PCT Basics: Obtaining Patent Rights Around the World Apr 27 2012
- Patent Strategy: Laying the Foundation for Business Success Apr 08 2012
- The Law of Recipes: Are Recipes Patentable? Feb 10 2012
- Patenting Board Games 101 Dec 22 2011
- Design Patents: The Under Utilized and Overlooked Patent Dec 20 2011
- The Benefits of a Provisional Patent Application Nov 26 2011
- PCT Basics: Understanding the International Filing Process Nov 03 2011
- An Overview of the PCT International Patent Process Aug 18 2011
For information on this and related topics please see these archives:
Posted in: Gene Quinn, IP News, IPWatchdog.com Articles, Patent Basics, Patents
About the Author
Gene Quinn is a US Patent Attorney, law professor and the founder of IPWatchdog.com. He is also a principal lecturer in the top patent bar review course in the nation, which helps aspiring patent attorneys and patent agents prepare themselves to pass the patent bar exam. Gene started the widely popular intellectual property website IPWatchdog.com in 1999, and since that time the site has had many millions of unique visitors. Gene has been quoted in the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, the LA Times, USA Today, CNN Money, NPR and various other newspapers and magazines worldwide. He represents individuals, small businesses and start-up corporations. As an electrical engineer with a computer engineering focus his specialty is electronic and computer devices, Internet applications, software and business methods.