Twentieth Century Fox Television Wins Trademark Case, ‘Empire’ Does Not Infringe

By Steve Brachmann
November 22, 2017

EmpireOn Thursday, November 16th, the Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit entered a ruling in a trademark case appealed from the Central District of California involving the Twentieth Century Fox Television show Empire. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the lower court’s ruling that the television show’s title was speech protected under the First Amendment and did not infringe upon trademarks owned by the multi-genre record label Empire Distribution.

Twentieth Century Fox first filed its complaint for declaratory relief in March 2015 seeking a judgment that Empire did not infringe on trademarks held by Empire Distribution. The suit followed a claim letter sent to Fox by Empire Distribution to inform Fox that it was using Empire’s trademarks in an unauthorized manner. During a telephone conference in March, Empire Distribution requested $8 million in damages to resolve the matter. Another claim letter sent in March to Fox informed the television producer that it could resolve the matter by paying $8 million in damages, $5 million in damages and promote artists represented by Empire Distribution as “regular guest stars,” or it could stop using the name Empire.

Fox had alleged that defendant Empire Distribution did not own a federally registered trademark covering the claimed “Empire” standard character mark. In February 2016, the California federal judge in the case entered a judgment finding in favor of plaintiff Fox’s motions on infringement, dilution and state unfair competition.

Empire Distribution appealed to the Ninth Circuit, arguing that the district court had erred substantively and procedurally in considering that Fox’s use of “Empire” was protected by the First Amendment and thus outside of reach of the Lanham Act. Unlike general claims of trademark infringement, claims of infringement involving the use of the mark in the title of an expressive work are subject to a two-pronged test developed by the Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in its 1989 decision in Rogers v. Grimaldi.

Applying the standard test set out in Rogers, the Ninth Circuit panel found that the first prong of the test was satisfied because the panel could not say that the “Empire” mark had no artistic relevance to the underlying work. The panel instead determined that the title Empire supported both the themes and the geographic setting of the work. The panel also found the the use of the “Empire” mark was not explicitly to mislead customers; the panel noted that the show Empire made no overt claims to Empire Distribution.

The Author

Steve Brachmann

Steve Brachmann is a writer located in Buffalo, New York. He has worked professionally as a freelancer for more than a decade. He has become a regular contributor to IPWatchdog.com, writing about technology, innovation and is the primary author of the Companies We Follow series. His work has been published by The Buffalo News, The Hamburg Sun, USAToday.com, Chron.com, Motley Fool and OpenLettersMonthly.com. Steve also provides website copy and documents for various business clients.

Warning & Disclaimer: The pages, articles and comments on IPWatchdog.com do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create any attorney-client relationship. The articles published express the personal opinion and views of the author and should not be attributed to the author’s employer, clients or the sponsors of IPWatchdog.com. Read more.

Discuss this

There are currently 1 Comment comments. Join the discussion.

  1. Valuationguy November 22, 2017 8:40 am

    I’m not following this case at all….but the reasoning of the Ninth Circuit panel spelled out by Steve sound like a load of crap….as the title certainly seems misleading to me….considering it is so similar to Empire Distribution…..an existing record label which just so happens to be what the show is entirely about (even if the actual label in the show is different).

    Appear more the overwhelming power of corporatism trumps the little guy.

    That being said…I’m going to guess that Empire Distribution can ride some coattails of the show in some creative ways to ensure it sees some benefit.

Post a Comment

Respectfully add to the discussion.

Name *
Email *
Website