Inventors inspired by humpback whales make a more efficient wind turbine

By Gene Quinn
April 24, 2018

Inventors inspired by humpback whales make a more efficient wind turbineInspired by the “bumpy” flippers of humpback whales, the team of Frank Fish, Stephen Dewar, and Philip Watts, innovated turbine blades with three-dimensional bumps on their leading edges that alter the flow of air, which greatly improves aerodynamic performance and quieter operation. For their efforts they have been named finalists for the 2018 European Inventor Awards by the European Patent Office.

“Dewar, Watts and Fish’s invention has the potential to make an impact on worldwide energy consumption, particularly as we increasingly rely on green technology,” said EPO President Benoit Battistelli announcing the European Inventor Award 2018 finalists. “Their work shows how nature can serve as a source of inspiration and innovation and how following this inspiration might lead to refreshing and unconventional technological advances.”



Whales show great efficiency, maneuverability and speed for their size and weight. It was this efficiency that fascinated biologist Frank Fish. He suspected the rugged shape of a humpback whale’s flippers, which are lined with irregular bumps known as tubercles, might be responsible for adding extra efficiency. Unlike other whales, explained Fish, “The humpback whale actively maneuvers to capture prey and the tubercles along with their long fins are important. Tubercles passively modify the flow over their wing-like flippers to give them greater lift and reduced drag.”

Fish wrote a research paper confirming his findings that captured the attention of aeronautical engineer Philip Watts. The two teamed up to more closely investigate the phenomenon and see if it might have practical applications. They showed that tubercles help to reduce water resistance at the tips of a whale’s flippers.

“Right away from our initial [test] results we saw some impressive data,” says Watts. “Once we had these results it was about going out into the real world and developing solutions. We were very surprised when these real-world applications lived up to and exceeded our expectations. It turned into an invention that keeps on giving.”

To realize the potential of the innovation, Fish and Watts joined forces with Canadian filmmaker, inventor and entrepreneur Stephen Dewar to develop, patent and market their new blade design. The three launched Canadian start-up WhalePower in 2005. With Frank Fish as President, Watts as Vice President of R&D, and Dewar as Vice-President of Operations, the company began licensing their designs to other companies that wanted to use the technology in their particular areas of expertise.

The company introduced the first Tubercle Blade HVLS (high-volume low-speed) fan to the market through a Canadian licensee and this industrial-scale fan is available in 38 countries. These fans offer 20,000 hours of maintenance free operation while consuming energy approximately that of an average household hair drier, and they circulate about 25% more air than similar non-tubercle fans. A second Chinese HVLS fan manufacturer also sells HVLS fans with tubercles throughout China.

In addition to an efficiency boost of approximately 20%, the noise from tubercle fans is reduced by at least 2 decibels when compared to non-tubercle fans, fatigue loads are reduced by 6%-8%, and the lifetime of components is extended by 25%. This all equates to an additional three to six years of use for a wind turbine.

WhalePower has also gone on to develop prototype fans for computer graphics cards, which tests have found to be about 20% more efficient than the current market leader.

 

The Author

Gene Quinn

Gene Quinn is a Patent Attorney and Editor and founder of IPWatchdog.com. Gene is also a principal lecturer in the PLI Patent Bar Review Course and an attorney with Widerman Malek. Gene’s specialty is in the area of strategic patent consulting, patent application drafting and patent prosecution. He consults with attorneys facing peculiar procedural issues at the Patent Office, advises investors and executives on patent law changes and pending litigation matters, and works with start-up businesses throughout the United States and around the world, primarily dealing with software and computer related innovations. is admitted to practice law in New Hampshire, is a Registered Patent Attorney and is also admitted to practice before the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. CLICK HERE to send Gene a message.

Warning & Disclaimer: The pages, articles and comments on IPWatchdog.com do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create any attorney-client relationship. The articles published express the personal opinion and views of the author and should not be attributed to the author’s employer, clients or the sponsors of IPWatchdog.com. Read more.

Discuss this

There are currently 3 Comments comments. Join the discussion.

  1. Robert Echavaria April 24, 2018 1:40 pm

    This concept for tubercles is not new, it is more than 12 years old. Unfortunately, it is aerodynamically not as efficient as a conventional serrated trailing edge. The original patent for a serrated trailing edge has already expired, which unfortunately devalues this concept. Many bio-mimetic concepts have been proposed for use on wind turbines, but they are unlikely to be adopted because inventors have not considered the impact on CapEx of the turbine, OpEx and how to service in case of damage (especially lightning strikes), as well as the non-recurring engineering cost to actually commercialize. This could be proposed as a retrofit solutions on older turbines, but there is already a lot of IP on those concepts and stiff commercial competition.

  2. Ternary April 24, 2018 3:53 pm

    What a cool invention and in such a cool field. The invention is cool to me, because it is counter-intuitive and in such a complex field. Then I thought: How unusual, a European start-up, relying on IP. Turns out that the inventors are Americans, and the company is Canadian. A patent application was filed in 2005 and the US patent was issued in 2013. The original invention (scalloped wing leading edge) goes back to at least 2000.

    The invention is very deserving of an award. But over 15 years after its first publication? And after it has become “politically correct?” This award really is not to support independent inventors, not in general, but certainly not in Europe. It all relies/relied on institutional support, with a highly institutional jury, long after the fact that inventors needed actual support. Sorry to say this, but it is an example of how the Europeans view and treat patents and inventors. And I am even sorrier to say that this is exactly the direction that our patent system is moving.

    Congratulations to Fish, Watts and Dewar for their amazing invention and persistence. Unfortunately their invention is based on “a million years of field tests” as they post on their website. Wait, that means that the invention is … conventional, routine (are you kidding millions of years) and well known (be it by artists and marine biologists). The fact that it took the genius of Fish to recognize its potential doesn’t mean that the functionality was not well established before the invention (according to Alice anyway).

  3. AAA JJ April 26, 2018 9:41 am

    Wait till the PTAB gets their hands on the patent. Invalid as ineligible subject matter (directed to a law of nature).

Post a Comment

Respectfully add to the discussion.

Name *
Email *
Website