Does the Internet of Things Recycle Old Technology?

By Julia Elvidge
November 23, 2015

internet-of-things-light-bulbThere is a lot of hype around the Internet of Things (IoT) yet many, if not most, are confused by what IoT really is and what it means for their IP and their business. If you are a new player in the IoT market, you most likely will be filing patent applications for new innovations; however, since IoT is being built on established technology, you need to be aware that there are hundreds of technology companies that may already own the seminal foundation patents. Many companies new to the IoT market may have strong and expansive portfolio positions for assertion. This makes it difficult at best to discern whether or not IoT inventions are really new or just recycled technology.

The IoT basically connects any device with an on/off switch to the Internet or to other devices. By adding sensors to everything and employing analytics; it enables new levels of efficiency and business refinement. This capability has fueled applications that span virtually every part of life, from sensing the walking cadence and heart rate of an elderly loved one through their slippers, to the remote wireless control of high voltage electric power grids. Virtually everything can be sensed and all at ultra-low costs. Today, the largest markets, which are driving billions of shipments per year in both silicon and devices, are medical, fitness wearables, industrial, automotive, and smart homes.

As a participant in the Internet of Things world, it’s important to have a high-level understanding of the five IoT technology segments and their patent landscapes, as well as a deeper understanding of the patent landscape of “Things.” IoT has five technology segments: Things, Networking, Computing & Storage, Services, and Analytics.

  • Things are sensors and actuators, mechanical devices that take energy and convert it into some type of motion. IoT sensors are inexpensive, very low power, wireless, and either disposable or “install and forget.” They are intended to work well but not perfectly, on aggregate data. Outlier data will be dropped. Sensors are asleep most of the time, but periodically wake up to transmit small bursts of data. The actuators may include automated controls, robots, or humans.
  • Networking includes a gateway, wireless infrastructure, and Internet transportation of data to the cloud. The gateway depends on the application and range of communication of the Things. The radio could be new Long-Range (LoRa) or established technologies like Bluetooth Low Energy, WiFi, or cellular. Gateways can be simple, or smart as those used in home IoT solutions. The network infrastructure today is very well established. Data pipes are larger in the downstream direction from cloud to gateways for high bandwidth applications like video. With IoT, the upstream pipe will become larger as well, so that it can carry data for the half billion Things forecast by 2020.
  • Computing and Storage of the full volume of sensor data is provided by big data systems. Big data computing and storage are well-established technologies that have been implemented widely in data centers, where data security is critical.
  • Services include Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS), and Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) and provide the means to deliver applications and services using the data for a particular client. These new IoT applications will include high reliability for medical, safety for automated cars, efficiency for manufacturing, and security for homes.
  • Analytics of broad amounts of IoT data will help identify IoT system refinements, using metrics and machine learning. This is a new area of technology, mostly software, where the goal is to look for operational or business metrics that allow a decision maker to make refinements and adjustments to each local IoT system. It also encompasses machine learning, which opens the door to a range of solutions.

The technology and patents for these five technology areas differ in content and maturity, with the technologies at the beginning of this system, Things, and at the end of this system, Analytics, being the newest. Despite the fact that the technologies in between, networking, computing and storage, and services, are established, they will need to evolve and scale for IoT. Therefore, while the IoT may leverage existing technology that may require licensing, it does not, as some claim, simply recycle old technology.

For designers working in the IoT markets, it is important to understand the patent landscape in order to avoid infringement or large licensing fees, especially in the “in between” areas where there is a dominance of mature companies and patents.
Many companies new to the IoT market may have strong and expansive portfolio positions for assertion. Even so, understanding the market players, their experience, and their patents in similar products, is vital in creating a product and IP strategy that can deliver a high return in the IoT market.

Chipworks completed analysis focusing on the Fitness and Wearables market segment to get a more detailed analysis of the patents and the players in this area. What we found was that given the diversity of technologies in IoT’s Things, the innovations in low power and analytics, and the wealth of established technology that is being repurposed for this market, there will be strong licensing positions held by a wide assortment of well established companies. Those companies entering the market will have to prepare for licensing by driving their rate of patent applications, purchasing patents, taking licenses, or being acquired as part of a round of market consolidation.

Overall, the Internet of Things will continue to evolve as we move beyond humans talking to machines, to machines talking to machines. Already the medical, fitness wearables, industry, automotive, and smart homes markets are driving billions of shipments per year in silicon and devices. Many other markets are poised to jump on the IoT bandwagon as the IoT permeates every facet of daily life. While new technology developed for the IoT will drive the growth of newly patented technology, it will also drive explosive growth in the patent licensing landscape as many of the patented technology being used in new ways for IoT Things is nearly 20 years old.

[Internet-Things]

The Author

Julia Elvidge

Julia Elvidge is the President of Chipworks. Her extensive knowledge of technology products and strategic issues involving intellectual property has enabled her to provide invaluable insight and guidance to Chipworks’ customers. A widely respected expert she has been recognized as one of the world’s most foremost IP strategists by Intellectual Property Magazine (IAM).

Warning & Disclaimer: The pages, articles and comments on IPWatchdog.com do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create any attorney-client relationship. The articles published express the personal opinion and views of the author and should not be attributed to the author’s employer, clients or the sponsors of IPWatchdog.com. Read more.

Discuss this

There are currently 2 Comments comments.

  1. American Cowboy November 24, 2015 9:48 am

    Back in the late 90’s there was a bunch of hype about having sensors in home appliances and many other IoT type end uses linked to the internet to achieve goals much like those hyped for IoT. Presumably, a lot of patent applications were filed then and matured into patents, either creating opportunities for infringement (if those patents have been maintained) or at least a minefield of prior art for new patents.

    What makes today’s IoT hype different from the late 90’s?

  2. John Willkie November 24, 2015 1:08 pm

    The Internet of Insecure Things is a great way for your refrigerator to send spam and “digital noise” to your toaster and tens of thousands of other insecure devices. This “service model” was not present in the previous hype iteration.