The week before Christmas brought the biggest post-grant review (PGR) bulk filing to date, with 10 matters all stemming from a pharmaceutical dispute between Allergan and BTL Medical Technologies (and one other, unrelated). That’s a steady average of 30 inter partes reviews (IPRs) propped up by the glut of 11 PGRs stemming from that dispute, discussed below. The 81 district court patent filings were again propped up by WSOU adding their usual dozen or so complaints and a new defendant, this time adding Salesforce to their ever-growing campaign asserting some of their 4,000 or so Nokia patents against seemingly the entire world.
Section 314 Denials Continue to Favor Large NPEs and Litigation-Funded Campaigns over Small Inventors: It seems beyond question at this point that Section 314 denials over trial dates have largely favored denial of institution for the most sophisticated litigation-focused (and wide-asserting) NPE entities pushing for district court trials. That includes a number of denials for Uniloc [Fortress], AGIS Software Development, LLC, Personalized Media Communications, LLC, VLSI Technology [Fortress], Solas OLED [Magnetar], and Optis Cellular Technology [Brevet Capital], to name a few. All have all benefited from suing on multiple patents and avoiding litigation-provoked validity challenges under the non-merits denial rules. Interestingly, some have resulted in some instituted, and others denied—in the Solas OLED matter, for instance, the LG case was denied (despite the International Trade Commission [ITC] trial being cancelled), but other challenges were instituted.
Setting the Tone: Medical device company BTL markets and sells an FDA-approved “body-contouring” device (Emsculpt®) that uses “high-intensity, focused electromagnetic energy to tone muscles” in ab, thigh, butt, and calve muscles for purely aesthetic purposes. More or less, it’s a method of applying magnets to muscles to provoke contractions, and it’s patent-protected. In 2017, Allergan acquired Zeltiq, a company then marketing the CoolSculpting® product, which is marketed as using cooling technology to reduce fat. In 2019, Allergan/Zeltiq began selling CoolTone®, a product that BTL now accuses Allergan and Zeltiq of willfully infringing at least five of their patents covering Emsculpt®. There must be plenty of money in these devices, because BTL filed both ITC and District Court complaints in September (in Delaware). Now Allergan & Co. have filed twelve post-grant challenges (to date)— 11 PGRs—All told, twelve challenges, one IPR and eleven PGRs. This may be one of the first really high-profile competitor/competitor suit involving a widely-marketed patented product new enough and successful enough that most of the patents qualify for PGRs, and it will be interesting to see how they all play out in light of the ITC action and the speed with which they were filed.
Uniloc Not Naming Fortress as a Party Despite District Court Ruling: Three weeks ago, a district court judge ruled that Uniloc Corporation Pty. Limited had defaulted on a credit agreement with Fortress in 2018, had not moved to cure, and, by not naming Fortress as the exclusive licensee in any matter then pending or later filed, lost (or in some cases never had) standing to maintain the action. Despite that public ruling, Uniloc has not moved to amend its pleadings in its many other matters in district court, on appeal, and before the Board—despite the fact that it would appear all of those matters now lack a necessary party, the exclusive licensee.
That case, Uniloc USA, Inc. et al v. Apple Inc., 3:18-cv-00358 ECF 186 (filed Dec. 4, 2020), noted that Uniloc was under an agreement to forfeit all control of their patents if they did not raise and return $20 million to Fortress—and they fell $6 million short, triggering the default. Which means that entity (and presumably others associated with it) needed to name Fortress as a necessary party—and hasn’t, to date—to have standing to file in the first place.
PTAB (41)
Case Number | Action | Owner | Petitioner | Patent |
PGR2021-00021 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10695575 |
IPR2021-00322 | Filed | HORIZON GLOBAL AMERICAS INC [Horizon Global Corp] | CONTINENTAL AUTOMOTIVE SYSTEMS, INC | 10040437 |
IPR2021-00324 | Filed | XRS Corporation [Omnitracks Holdings, LLC] | Platform Science, Inc | 9262934 |
IPR2021-00342 | Filed | Icon Health and Fitness Inc. | Peloton Interactive, Inc. | 7166062 |
IPR2021-00299 | Filed | Universal Electronics, Inc. | Roku, Inc. | 10593196 |
IPR2021-00262 | Filed | Universal Electronics, Inc. | Roku, Inc. | 7969514 |
IPR2021-00280 | Filed | Natera, Inc. | Progenity, Inc. | 9228234 |
IPR2021-00281 | Filed | Natera, Inc. | Progenity, Inc. | 10522242 |
IPR2021-00305 | Filed | Koss Corp. | Apple, Inc. | 10506325 |
IPR2021-00321 | Filed | HORIZON GLOBAL AMERICAS INC | CONTINENTAL AUTOMOTIVE SYSTEMS, INC | 9758138 |
IPR2021-00047 | Filed | Maxell, Ltd. [Hitachi] | Apple Inc. | 7203517 |
IPR2021-00263 | Filed | Universal Electronics, Inc. | Roku, Inc. | 10600317 |
IPR2021-00303 | Filed | AVAGO TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL SALES PTE. LIMITED | NETFLIX, INC. | 8270992 |
IPR2021-00312 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O. | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10478634 |
PGR2021-00015 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O. | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10709895 |
PGR2021-00024 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O. | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10695576 |
IPR2021-00293 | Filed | C. A. Casyso GMBH | HemoSonics LLC | 10746750 |
IPR2021-00347 | Filed | Risen Pharma Tech Co., Ltd. | Alzheon, Inc. | 10472323 |
IPR2021-00291 | Filed | Capella Photonics, Inc. | Cisco Systems, Inc. | RE47906 |
PGR2021-00025 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ALLERGAN, INC., ELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10695576 |
IPR2021-00296 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10493293 |
IPR2021-00323 | Filed | XRS Corporation [Omnitracks Holdings] | Platform Science, Inc | 8626568 |
IPR2021-00320 | Filed | HORIZON GLOBAL AMERICAS INC | CONTINENTAL AUTOMOTIVE SYSTEMS, INC | 8789896 |
IPR2021-00319 | Filed | Oyster Optics LLC | CISCO SYSTEMS, INC | 6665500 |
IPR2021-00318 | Filed | Interactive Play Devices LLC [Empire IP] | Spin Master Inc. | 7491108 |
IPR2021-00325 | Filed | XRS Corporation [Omnitracks Holdings] | Platform Science, Inc | 10255575 |
PGR2021-00016 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10709895 |
IPR2021-00264 | Filed | Universal Electronics, Inc. | Roku, Inc. | 10600317 |
PGR2021-00017 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10632321 |
PGR2021-00023 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10709894 |
PGR2021-00020 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10695575 |
PGR2021-00022 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O., | ALLERGAN, INC., ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC., ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC., ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY, et al. |
10709894 |
IPR2021-00261 | Filed | Universal Electronics, Inc. | Roku, Inc. | 7969514 |
PGR2021-00026 | Filed | THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO | MICROSURGICAL TECHNOLOGY, INC | 10786391 |
IPR2021-00290 | Filed | Capella Photonics, Inc. | Cisco Systems, Inc. | RE47905 |
IPR2021-00314 | Filed | Interactive Play Devices LLC [Empire IP] | Spin Master Inc. | 7491111 |
IPR2021-00313 | Filed | Interactive Play Devices LLC [Empire IP] | Spin Master Inc. | 7491108 |
IPR2021-00292 | Filed | Capella Photonics, Inc. | Cisco Systems, Inc. | RE47906 |
PGR2021-00018 | Filed | BTL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES S.R.O | ALLERGAN, INC ALLERGAN LIMITED ALLERGAN USA, INC ZELTIQ AESTHETICS, INC ZELTIQ IRELAND UNLIMITED COMPANY et al. |
10632321 |
IPR2021-00326 | Filed | AMGEN, INC. | LUPIN, LTD LUPIN PHARMACEUTICALS, INC |
9856287 |
IPR2020-00614 | Not Instituted – Merits | Divx, LLC [Fortress IP, Softbank] | Netflix, Inc. Hulu, LLC |
7295673 |
IPR2020-01068 | Not Instituted – Merits | Green Mountain Glass, LLC Culchrome LLC |
O-I Glass, Inc Owens-Brockway Glass Container Inc. |
5718737 |
PGR2020-00068 | Not Instituted – Merits | Exela Pharma Sciences, LLC | Eton Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | 10583155 |
IPR2020-01121 | Not Instituted – Merits | Jodi A. Schwendimann Jodi A. Dalvey Nucoat, Inc. |
STAHLS’ Inc | 7771554 |
IPR2020-01055 | Not Instituted – Procedural | Solas Oled, Ltd. [Magentar Capital] | LG Display Co., Ltd. | 7907137 |
IPR2020-01122 | Instituted | Jodi A. Schwendimann Jodi A. Dalvey Nucoat, Inc. |
STAHLS’ Inc | 7766475 |
IPR2020-01003 | Instituted | Innovative Foundry Technologies LLC | SMIC, Americas | 6580122 |
IPR2020-01042 | Instituted | Netlist, Inc. | SK Hynix, Inc. SK Hynix America, Inc. |
10474595 |
IPR2020-01000 | Instituted | Neodron Ltd. [Magnetar Capital] | Apple Inc. Microsoft Corporation |
8749251 |
IPR2020-01063 | Instituted | Impinj, Inc. | NXP USA, Inc | 8390431 |
PGR2020-00051 | Instituted | Yantai Ausbio Laboratories Co., Ltd. | Bluecatbio Ma Inc. | 10338063 |
IPR2020-01735 | Instituted | Invensas Corporation [Xperi Corp., TiVo, Rovi] | Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC (d/b/a ON Semicondutor) Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC d/b/a ON Semiconductor |
6849946 |
IPR2020-01067 | Instituted | Hammond Development International, Inc. | Amazon.com LLC | 10270816 |
IPR2020-01018 | Instituted | Voice Tech Corporation | Unified Patents, LLC | 10491679 |
IPR2020-01029 | Instituted | Hammond Development International, Inc. | Amazon.com LLC Amazon.com, Inc. |
10264032 |
IPR2020-00983 | Instituted | NavBlazer, LLC [Raymond Anthony Joao] | Unified Patents, LLC | 9885782 |
IPR2020-00603 | Instituted | Invensas Corporation [Xperi Corp., TiVo, Rovi] | NVIDIA Corporation Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC d/b/a ON Semiconductor |
6232231 |
IPR2020-01017 | Instituted | Monterey Research, LLC [Vector Capital Corp.] | Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. | 6961807 |
IPR2020-00998 | Instituted | Neodron Ltd. [Magentar Capital] | Apple Inc. Microsoft Corporation APPLE INC MICROSOFT CORPORATION |
8749251 |
IPR2020-01062 | Instituted | Impinj, Inc. | NXP USA, Inc | 8134451 |
IPR2020-01026 | Instituted | Caravan Canopy International, Inc. | Walmart Inc. | 5944040 |
IPR2020-00140 | Instituted | Solas Oled, Ltd. [Magnetar Capital] | Samsung Dell, Inc. Samsung Display Co., Ltd. Apple Inc. |
6072450 |
IPR2020-01059 | Instituted | Solas Oled, Ltd. [Magnetar Capital] | Apple Inc. | 6072450 |
IPR2020-00602 | Instituted | Invensas Corporation | NVIDIA Corporation Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC d/b/a ON Semiconductor |
6849946 |
IPR2020-01729 | Instituted | Invensas Corporation | Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC (d/b/a ON Semicondutor) Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC d/b/a ON Semiconductor |
6232231 |
IPR2020-01044 | Instituted | Netlist, Inc. | SK Hynix, Inc. SK Hynix America, Inc. |
9858218 |
IPR2020-01070 | Instituted | Sisvel International S.A. [Fineur Int’l S.A.] | Cradlepoint, Inc., Dell, Inc. Sierra Wireless, Inc. Thales Dis Ais Deutschland Gmbh ZTE Corporation et al. |
7433698 |
IPR2019-01252 | Final Written Decision | Reuben Bahar Uniloc 2017 LLC [Fortress IP, Softbank] |
Microsoft Corporation | 7024696 |
IPR2019-01168 | Final Written Decision | Contemporary Display LLC [IP Valuation Partners] | Dish Network Corporation | 6492997 |
IPR2019-01251 | Final Written Decision | Reuben Bahar Uniloc 2017 LLC [Fortress IP, Softbank] |
Microsoft Corporation | 8613110 |
IPR2019-01051 | Final Written Decision | Deere & Company | Precision Planting, LLC AGCO Corporation AGCO CORP |
9807924 |
IPR2019-01202 | Final Written Decision | ITW Global Tire Repair Inc. Illinois Tool Works, Inc. |
Trydel Research Pty Ltd. | 7388041 |
IPR2019-01263 | Final Written Decision | Omnivision Technologies, Inc. | Jiangu Smartsens Technology Co., Ltd. Smartsens Technology (US) Inc. SMARTSENS TECHNOLOGY (US) INC |
7145122 |
IPR2019-01055 | Final Written Decision | Deere & Company | Precision Planting, LLC AGCO Corporation AGCO CORP |
9699955 |
District Court (82)
Case Number | Action | Plaintiff | Defendant | Patent |
1:20-cv-06082 | Filed | Edge Specialists, LLC | Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC | 9550052 9775646 8066716 8337513 6641591 |
6:20-cv-01142 | Filed | Lexos Media IP, LLC [Lexos Media, Inc.] | Urban Outfitters, Inc. | 5995102 6118449 |
2:20-cv-00383 | Filed | NorthStar Systems LLC [Alpha Alpha Intellectual Partners] | TCL Multimedia Technology Holdings, Ltd. TCT Mobile International Limited |
8805416 6995708 8478527 8014943 8032297 7817085 7327312 8717231 |
2:20-cv-19295 | Filed | ACROTECH BIOPHARMA LLC CyDex Pharmaceuticals, Inc. |
Alembic Pharmaceuticals, LTD Alembic |
10864183 |
2:20-cv-06082 | Filed | Edge Specialists, LLC | Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC | 9775646 6641591 8066716 8337513 9550052 |
1:20-cv-01222 | Filed | Bandspeed, LLC | Intel Corp. | 7027418 7570614 8873500 7477624 7903608 8542643 10602528 10791565 9379769 9883520 |
3:20-cv-19295 | Filed | ACROTECH BIOPHARMA LLC CyDex Pharmaceuticals, Inc. |
Alembic Pharmaceuticals, LTD Alembic |
10864183 |
6:20-cv-01156 | Filed | Lexos Media IP, LLC | Gift Services, Inc. | 5995102 6118449 |
1:20-cv-01708 | Filed | Koninklijke Philips | Telit Communications PLC Telit Wireless Solutions, Inc. |
9178577 7089028 9635599 8195216 8134929 10257814 |
1:20-cv-01713 | Filed | Koninklijke Philips | Thales USA, Inc. THALES S.A. Calamp Corp. Laird Connectivity, Inc. Thales DIS AIS Deutschland GmbH et al. |
7944935 7831271 7554943 8199711 |
1:20-cv-05103 | Filed | Southeastern Underdeck Systems, LLC | All South Rain Solutions, LLC | 9187911 |
1:20-cv-01216 | Filed | Knape & Vogt Manufacturing Company | Design Ideas, Limited | D624753 D847510 D895291 D856678 7428976 8006858 8584889 10524569 |
8:20-cv-02378 | Filed | FKA Distributing Co., LLC dba HoMedics | Merchsource | 7303300 7652436 7722553 10413472 |
1:20-cv-01718 | Filed | Guada Technologies, LLC [IP Edge] | Ply Gem Industries, Inc. | 7231379 |
4:20-cv-00389 | Filed | John Deere Shared Services, Inc.; Deere & Co. | AG Leader Technology, Inc.; Kinze Manufacturing, Inc. | 8813663 9480199 8850998 10729063 9693498 9861031 9807924 9686906 |
6:20-cv-01161 | Filed | Aeritas, LLC | WestJet Airlines, Ltd | 8620364 9390435 9888107 7933589 7209903 10362160 7706819 |
6:20-cv-01166 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 8335819 |
6:20-cv-01167 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 8369827 |
6:20-cv-01169 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 8923899 |
6:20-cv-01170 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 9088493 |
2:20-cv-11287 | Filed | Display Technologies, LLC [Leigh Rothschild] | Paedae, Inc. dba Gimbal | 9300723 |
5:20-cv-02571 | Filed | Knolly Bikes Inc. | Intense Cycles, Inc. | 10363988 |
3:20-cv-08845 | Filed | Social Positioning Input Systems, LLC [Leigh Rothschild] | Azuga, Inc. | 9261365 |
2:20-cv-02465 | Filed | Xiaohua Huang | Sapia Networks, Inc. | 6999331 |
2:20-cv-00385 | Filed | NorthStar Systems LLC [Alpha Alpha Intellectual Partners] | Shenzhen OnePlus Science & Technology Co., Ltd. | 8717231 8805416 8032297 6995708 8478527 8014943 7817085 7327312 |
1:20-cv-03665 | Filed | PerfX Wireline Services, LLC | DMC Global, Inc. DynaEnergetics Europe GmbH DynaEnergetics US, Inc. |
10844697 |
5:20-cv-00471 | Filed | MEERKAT TECHNOLOGIES INC | DRIFT NET LLC | 10810845 |
3:20-cv-01341 | Filed | AML IP, LLC [Dynamic IP Deals, LLC d/b/a/ DynaIP] | BAKKT HOLDINGS, LLC BAKKT MARKETPLACE, LLC BAKKT TRUST COMPANY LLC BAKKT CLEARING, LLC |
7328189 |
3:20-cv-01108 | Filed | National Products Inc. | Gamber-Johnson, LLC | 9706026 |
2:20-cv-00387 | Filed | Be Labs, Inc. | Fortinet, Inc. | 7827581 9344183 |
6:20-cv-01151 | Filed | Symmetrix Video Systems LLC [Jeffrey M. Gross] | Cisco Systems, Inc. | 10547811 |
1:20-cv-01709 | Filed | Koninklijke Philips | Thales DIS AIS USA LLC Thales USA, Inc. THALES S.A. Thales DIS AIS Deutschland GmbH |
9178577 7089028 9635599 8195216 8134929 10257814 |
3:20-cv-19578 | Filed | GALDERMA HOLDING SA Galderma Laboratories |
Cadila Healthcare | 9089587 9233117 9782425 10206939 9233118 |
1:20-cv-25144 | Filed | Jetaire Aerospace, LLC | AerSale Inc. | 9849998 10633109 10800541 |
2:20-cv-00389 | Filed | PROVEN NETWORKS, LLC [Provenance Asset Group] | Palo Alto Networks, Inc. | 8018852 8165024 |
1:20-cv-01717 | Filed | Altair Logix LLC [IP Edge] | Outform, Inc. | 6289434 |
6:20-cv-01163 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 7551731 |
6:20-cv-01165 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 8280928 |
2:20-cv-11317 | Filed | T&M Inventions, LLC [TM Patents] | R&S Manufacturing and Sales Company, Inc. | 8438798 8438799 8438801 |
2:20-cv-18972 | Filed | Merck Sharp & Dohme B.V. ORGANON USA INC |
Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited Teva Pharmaceutical |
RE44733 |
8:20-cv-02968 | Filed | SYNGENTA CROP PROTECTION, LLC | Atticus, Inc. | |
2:20-cv-00384 | Filed | NorthStar Systems LLC [Alpha Alpha Intellectual Partners LLC] | Kyocera Corp. | 8805416 6995708 8032297 8478527 8014943 7817085 7327312 8717231 |
2:20-cv-00386 | Filed | NorthStar Systems LLC [Alpha Alpha Intellectual Partners LLC] | ZTE | 8717231 8805416 8032297 6995708 8478527 8014943 7817085 7327312 |
2:20-cv-04332 | Filed | EmeryAllen LLC | Maxlite, Inc. | 10605412 D850663 |
1:20-cv-01707 | Filed | Koninklijke Philips | Quectel Wireless Solutions Co. Ltd. | 9635599 7089028 9178577 8195216 8134929 10257814 |
1:20-cv-01710 | Filed | Koninklijke Philips | Quectel Wireless Solutions Co. Ltd. Laird Connectivity, Inc. Xirgo Technologies, LLC Calamp Corp. |
7944935 7831271 7554943 8199711 |
2:20-cv-11484 | Filed | Lightside Technologies, LLC | SunBriteTV, LLC | 5999220 8228979 6370198 |
1:20-cv-01721 | Filed | Revolar Technology, Inc. | Occly LLC | 7486194 |
1:20-cv-01725 | Filed | Digi Portal LLC [IP Edge] | CarMax, Inc. | 8352854 5983227 9626342 7171414 7565359 |
2:20-cv-19805 | Filed | AURINIA PHARMACEUTICALS INC. | Sun Pharmaceutical | 10265375 |
6:20-cv-01168 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 8391892 |
6:20-cv-01171 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 9277060 |
6:20-cv-01172 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 9336320 |
2:20-cv-11301 | Filed | Tee Turtle, LLC, a Missouri limited liability company | Kellytoy (USA), Inc. Kellytoy Worldwide, Inc. |
D822127 D836168 D860337 10786746 |
2:20-cv-00382 | Filed | Mad Dogg Athletics, Inc. | Peloton Interactive, Inc. | 9694240 10137328 |
1:20-cv-01694 | Filed | Modoral Brands Inc. | NYZ AB Swedish Match North America LLC Pinkerton Tobacco Co. LP |
9161908 |
3:20-cv-03636 | Filed | Blue Yonder Group Inc | Kinaxis Corp Kinaxis Inc |
6591153 7050874 7574383 7788145 8781868 10572856 |
6:20-cv-01141 | Filed | Caselas, LLC [Raymond Anthony Joao] | TruWest Credit Union | 7529698 7661585 9117206 9117230 9715691 |
8:20-cv-02364 | Filed | CIPM, LLC | 10717020 | |
1:20-cv-19379 | Filed | Salix Pharmaceuticals Norgine B.V. BAUSCH HEALTH IRELAND LIMITED |
Lupin Limited | 10780112 10792306 |
6:20-cv-01148 | Filed | Browse3D LLC | Adidas | |
6:20-cv-01149 | Filed | Be Labs, Inc. | Accton Technology Co. | 7827581 9344183 |
3:20-cv-09148 | Filed | People.ai, Inc. | SetSail Technologies, Inc. | 10679001 10565229 10496634 10657129 |
6:20-cv-04353 | Filed | LARRY GOLDEN | AT&T, Inc. Fairway Ford Lincoln of Greenville FCA US LLC QUALCOMM INC Sprint Corporation et al. |
|
1:20-cv-01715 | Filed | Caldwell Manufacturing Company, LLC | Amesbury Industries, Inc. | 10704308 |
1:20-cv-01723 | Filed | Digi Portal LLC [IP Edge] | Aveda Corp. | 8352854 5983227 9626342 7171414 7565359 |
3:20-cv-19805 | Filed | AURINIA PHARMACEUTICALS INC. | Sun Pharmaceutical | 10265375 |
6:20-cv-01164 | Filed | WSOU Investments, LLC dba Brazos Licensing and Development [WSOU Holdings, Craig Etchegoyen] | Salesforce.com | 8209411 |
3:20-cv-08840 | Filed | Scanning Technologies Innovations, LLC [Leigh Rothschild] | Sortly, Inc. | 10600101 |
1:20-cv-12219 | Filed | RSCC Wire & Cable LLC [Berkshire Hathaway] | Prysmian Cable and Systems USA, LLC | 7339115 |
3:20-cv-03639 | Filed | NLB Corp. | Bingham Manufacturing, Inc., d/b/a Bingham Industries | 7600700 8251301 |
3:20-cv-00376 | Filed | G&H Diversified Manufacturing, LP DynaEnergetics Europe GmbH DynaEnergetics US, Inc. |
10844697 | |
8:20-mc-00108 | Filed | SYNGENTA CROP PROTECTION, LLC | Atticus, Inc. | |
6:20-cv-01150 | Filed | Be Labs, Inc. | TP-Link Technology Co., LTD. | 7827581 9344183 |
6:20-cv-01152 | Filed | Daedalus Blue, LLC [Poss. IBM] | Microsoft | 7177886 8572612 8671132 7437730 8381209 |
1:20-cv-01711 | Filed | Koninklijke Philips | Telit Communications PLC Calamp Corp. Telit Wireless Solutions, Inc. |
7944935 7831271 7554943 8199711 |
1:20-cv-25141 | Filed | Jetaire Aerospace, LLC | AerSale Inc. | |
6:20-cv-01157 | Filed | Glu Mobile, Inc. | Reworks Oy | 10504297 |
2:20-cv-11478 | Filed | National Products Inc. | Scosche Industries | 6585212 |
1:20-cv-01719 | Filed | Guada Technologies, LLC [IP Edge] | GAF Materials LLC | 7231379 |
1:20-cv-19578 | Filed | GALDERMA HOLDING SA Galderma Laboratories |
Cadila Healthcare | 9089587 10206939 9782425 9233118 9233117 |
Rights acquired by AdobeStock
Join the Discussion
No comments yet.